What Is a Hardware Token? Comparing Authentication Methods

What Is a Hardware Token?

A hardware token is a physical device used to verify a user’s identity during login. It serves as the second factor in multi-factor authentication (MFA), alongside a password. Unlike software tokens, hardware tokens operate independently from smartphones or computers, reducing exposure to malware, phishing, or device compromise. These secure authentication methods help protect access to user accounts.

Examples include:

• USB devices (e.g., YubiKeys)
• OTP (one-time password) key fobs
• Smart cards with embedded chips
• NFC/Bluetooth-enabled tokens for wireless authentication

These devices support various authentication standards such as FIDO2, HOTP, TOTP, and PKI. Some hardware tokens act as disconnected tokens that generate authentication codes without an internet connection.

Why Hardware Tokens Are Essential in 2025

Password-only security is insufficient. Credentials are often stolen in breaches, reused across accounts, or phished via email. MFA mitigates this by requiring something the user knows (a password) and something the user has (a token).

Benefits of hardware tokens:

• More robust defence against device-level malware attacks
• Generally resistant to SIM-swapping or man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks
• Offer reliable offline authentication
• Can assist in measuring up to major compliance frameworks (e.g., PCI DSS, NIST SP 800-63B, FIPS 140-2)

Comparing Hardware Tokens to Software-Based MFA

Location: Hardware tokens are separate physical devices, while software tokens run on a mobile or desktop app.

Security: Hardware tokens offer high security because they are physically isolated; software tokens are more vulnerable as they rely on operating systems.

Phishing Resistance: Hardware tokens provide strong resistance to phishing, unlike software tokens which can be intercepted or cloned.

Offline Use: Hardware tokens function offline; some software tokens do, depending on the app.

Portability: Software tokens are highly portable and convenient, while hardware tokens require the user to carry an extra physical object.

Cost: Hardware tokens involve higher costs due to device purchase and distribution. Software tokens are generally low-cost or free.

Hard and soft tokens each have trade-offs. Soft tokens offer more user convenience but carry higher security risks if mobile phones are compromised.

How Hardware Tokens Work

Most hardware tokens operate using one of the following methods:

• OTP (TOTP/HOTP): Token generates time- or event-based codes, verified by the server.
• FIDO2/WebAuthn: Uses public-key cryptography and biometric support.
• Smart card/PKI: Token contains private cryptographic keys for certificate-based login.

Typical authentication flow:

• User enters username and password
• Server prompts for second factor
• User inserts token or taps it
• Access is granted if valid

This authentication process ensures that only an authorized user with physical possession of the token can gain access.

When to Deploy Hardware Tokens

Hardware tokens should be prioritized for:

• Privileged users (admins, executives)
• VPN and remote access endpoints
• Cloud admin consoles
• High-value data environments
• ICS/OT systems in critical infrastructure

For organizations with elevated risk exposure or compliance needs, hardware tokens should be the default for MFA. Security token adoption can also support access control policies across multiple systems.

Example Use Cases Across Industries

• Finance: Bank employees authenticate into payment systems with FIDO2 tokens instead of SMS codes.
• Healthcare: Clinicians use smart cards to access electronic health records (EHRs) securely and remain HIPAA-compliant.
• Government: Agencies deploy tokens for identity assurance and digital signature enforcement.
• Technology: DevOps teams use YubiKeys to secure code repositories, internal CI/CD tools, and production dashboards.

Implementation Considerations

Procurement and Inventory Management:

• Track token issuance and revocation
• Plan for loss or damage replacement
• Store backup tokens securely for emergency access

Lifecycle Controls:

• Tokens expire or become outdated; refresh periodically
• Retire tokens when employees exit or change roles

End-User Education:

• Provide onboarding guidance and visual aids
• Train users on proper handling, backup access, and reporting loss

Device Compatibility:

• Consider support for USB-A, USB-C, NFC, and mobile integrations
• Test tokens across OS environments (Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android)

Challenges and Limitations

• Lost or stolen tokens: Users may misplace devices or become victims of theft. Mitigation includes backup codes and reissuance protocols.
• Initial cost: Tokens have upfront costs and require logistics planning.
• User resistance: Employees unfamiliar with tokens may resist adoption. Clear training helps reduce friction.
• Scalability: For large, distributed teams, management can be resource-intensive without centralized tracking tools.

Despite these limitations, hardware tokens offer security advantages that far outweigh their operational costs—especially in regulated or targeted sectors. Many users benefit from the added layer of security without sacrificing intended device compatibility.

Why Hardware Tokens Outperform SMS MFA

Many organizations and individuals still rely on SMS-based MFA. But it comes with critical weaknesses, including susceptibility to SIM swapping or social engineering attacks.

In contrast, hardware tokens:

• Store secrets in tamper-resistant chips
• Require physical presence

As phishing kits and MFA bypass tools grow more sophisticated, phishing-resistant methods like FIDO2 are critical. Hardware security tokens and disconnected tokens add an additional layer of defense in complex environments.

Organizations with widespread hardware token adoption benefit from higher cyber hygiene and improved insurability.

Protect Your Supply Chain with Real-Time Threat Detection SecurityScorecard’s SCDR solution offers continuous monitoring of your third-party ecosystem, enabling swift identification and mitigation of cyber threats. Strengthen authentication practices across your vendor network. 🔗 Understand SCDR