Competitive Comparison

SecurityScorecard vs Black Kite

Why customers choose SecurityScorecard over Black Kite

Data Ownership & Quality

99.9% of our data is collected directly by SecurityScorecard — no third-party sources, no accuracy gaps

Comprehensive Platform

Custom scorecards and AI-driven questionnaires deliver tailored, thorough vendor risk assessments

Managed TPRM Services

TITAN MAX delivers full TPRM program management — from questionnaires to complete program oversight

Proven where others fall short

SecurityScorecard

Unparalleled Accuracy and Transparency

SecurityScorecard collects 99.9% of the data utilized by TITAN. This ensures that data presented is curated and reconciled directly by SecurityScorecard, but that any updates or needed refinements happen quickly.

  • Data accuracy and correction speeds are public, not hidden
  • < 4 hours average response time to remediate inaccuracies
Schedule a Demo Today!
99.9%
of our data is collected by us
on average

Comprehensive Platform

SecurityScorecard delivers a complete Vendor risk management solution. Custom scorecards allow risk managers to tailor their lens to the specific elements of a vendor that matter, while our comprehensive assessment and questionnaire capabilities ensure that all relevant details regarding a vendor’s security and compliance posture are surfaced and accounted for.

  • Custom scorecards and AI-driven questionnaires deliver tailored, thorough vendor risk assessments
Schedule a TITAN AI Demo Today!
12M
TITAN AI accurately maps risk signals
to over 12 million rated organizations
SecurityScorecard
SecurityScorecard

MAX: Your TPRM Program, Fully Managed

MAX Services provide a comprehensive suite of management offerings for your TPRM program.

  • MAX Questionnaires enable customers to offload one of the most demanding yet vital aspects of the TPRM to our experts, while still enabling the customer to manage the overall program
  • MAX Monitor enables customers to offload the day-to-day management of their TPRM Program, freeing up key resources
  • MAX Respond handles vendor engagement and escalation when potential risks or issues are identified within the supply chain
Schedule a MAX Demo Today!
66%
reduction in vendor questionnaire completion times

See what our customers think

video-poster
Moving over to SecurityScorecard has been a much better method. It not only allows us to review vendor security—it also lets us assess our own systems, which our previous tool didn’t support.”
Jon Elmquist
Chief Risk Officer
video-poster
I absolutely recommend SecurityScorecard. I can call them anytime I want or send them a note and they will respond immediately. The support at SecurityScorecard wins us a lot of of credibility with vendors because the data is accurate.”
Steve Daknis
Manager, Third-Party Risk, Aflac
We’re delighted to be the first to integrate hacker insights from vulnerability disclosure and bug bounty reports into the consolidated visibility provided by SecurityScorecard. Knowing how quickly suppliers and partners respond to vulnerability reports and who ignores these findings entirely empowers security leaders to make better, more secure decisions.”
Alex Rice
CTO and Co-Founder, HackerOne
Hackerone Logo
Hackerone Logo
We brought in SecurityScorecard as part of the conversation and talked through some of the potential root causes, and there were about three or four that they had to work through. Ultimately, the score was cleaned up, and it just promoted a pretty transparent dialogue with the prospective third party.”
Andy Abananti
Corporate Vice President at New York Life
Compare platforms
Black Kite
SecurityScorecard
Data ownership
Buys much of their data from third party sources. Can’t directly assert for accuracy or completeness
Owns 99.9%
Performance Transparency
Claims rapid refresh rates, but does not offer live visibility into accuracy rate or correction speed. This would be complicated regarding the data they purchase instead of obtain directly
Accuracy and correction speeds are fully transparent on the SecurityScorecard trust page
Custom Rating Scope
Vendors can only be rated based on their defined organizational structure
Customers can create a custom scorecard for their vendors which enable ratings and scoring specific and tailored to the elements of a vendor that are of specific interest to a customer, giving a much more accurate view of risk
Vendor Assessments
You rely on what evidence documents a vendor is willing to share with you. No way to evaluate a vendor directly via questionnaires
Securityscorecard leverages a combination of AI driven Evidence collection and ingestion, combined with flexible questionnaires to ensure assessments are thorough and complete
Services
Services cover onboarding and Ad-Hoc Solutions Consulting meant to support customer operation
MAX offers customers a range of supporting services ranging from questionnaire and assessment management up to full TPRM program management

Compare SecurityScorecard with other tools

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do SecurityScorecard and Black Kite differ in scope for organizations that need GRC, due diligence, and operational risk capabilities?

Black Kite is primarily focused on cyber risk monitoring and financial quantification — it is not designed to support broader due diligence, GRC workflows, or operational risk requirements such as compliance evidence management, onboarding workflows, or governance integration. Organizations with multi-dimensional vendor risk programs that span cyber and non-cyber risk factors will encounter coverage gaps with Black Kite. SecurityScorecard’s platform extends across security ratings, GRC integration, compliance automation, questionnaire management, and in-house professional services — making it a more complete solution for programs that require more than cyber risk scoring alone.

How do vendor access models differ between SecurityScorecard and Black Kite, and why does it matter for remediation programs?

Vendor access models directly affect the practical effectiveness of risk remediation programs. Black Kite limits supplier platform access to 14 days — after which vendors must obtain a paid license to continue viewing their findings or tracking remediation progress. SecurityScorecard provides vendors with permanent, free access to their scorecard, including the ability to dispute findings and monitor remediation progress on an ongoing basis. Permanent free vendor access removes a common barrier to supplier engagement and supports more collaborative, continuous improvement in vendor risk posture without requiring vendors to absorb additional cost.

SecurityScorecard

Beyond cyber. TITAN sees everything.