• Support
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Support
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Blog
SecurityScorecard SecurityScorecard
  • Products
    PRODUCTS
    • Security Ratings
      Identify security strengths across ten risk factors.
    • Security Data
      Get actionable, data-based insights.
    • Security Assessments
      Automate security questionnaire exchange.
    • Attack Surface Intelligence
      NEW
      On-demand contextualized global threat intelligence.
     
    • Automatic Vendor Detection
      Uncover your third and fourth party vendors.
    • Cyber Risk Quantification
      Translate cyber risk into financial impact.
    • Reporting Center
      Streamline cyber risk reporting.
    • SecurityScorecard Marketplace
      Discover and deploy pre-built integrations.
    BUY NOW
    • Compare All Plans
      Choose a plan that's right for your business.
    • Try Free Account
      Make informed decisions with confidence.
    • Buy Pro Now
      Add automated event responses.
    • Buy Business Now
      Expand on Pro with vendor management and integrations.
    • Request Enterprise Demo
      See the capabilities of an enterprise plan in action.
    icon__SSClogoMark icon__SSClogoMark

    Understand and reduce risk with SecurityScorecard.

    Free account sign up
  • Services
    SERVICES NEW
    • Digital Forensics & Incident Response
      Prepare to respond to any threat.
    • Third-Party Risk Management
      Reduce risk across your vendor ecosystem.
    • Cyber Risk Intelligence
      Partner to obtain meaningful threat intelligence.
     
    • Penetration Testing
      Uncover your vulnerabilities before an attack does.
    • Red Team
      Use scenarios to perform a simulated attack.
    • Tabletop Exercises
      Test your incident response plan & bolster your readiness.

    Under Cyber attack?

    Contact us for immediate support if you believe your organization is the victim of a cyber attack.

    Contact Cyber 911 Team
  • Solutions
    BY USE CASE
    • Compliance
    • Cyber Insurance
    • Digital Forensics
    • Due Diligence
    • Enterprise Cyber Risk
    • Executive-Level Reporting
    • Incident Response
    • Regulatory Oversight
    • Third-Party Risk
    BY INDUSTRY
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Financial Services
    • Government
    • Healthcare
    • Insurance
    • Retail & Consumer
    • Technology
    Help your organization calculate its risk
    View All Solutions
  • Customers
    OUR CUSTOMERS
    • Customer Overview
      Trusted by companies of all industries and sizes.
    • Peer Reviews
      Find out what our customers are saying.
    SUCCESS AND SUPPORT
    • Customer Success
      Receive award-winning customer service.
    • Support
      Get your questions answered by our experts.
    COMMUNITY
    • SecurityScorecard Connect
      Engage in fun, educational, and rewarding activities.
    • Connect Login
      Join our exclusive online customer community.
    icon__SSClogoMark icon__SSClogoMark
    Understand and reduce risk with SecurityScorecard.
    Free account sign up
  • Partners

    Partner Program Overview

    Partner with SecurityScorecard and leverage our global cybersecurity ratings leadership to expand your solution, deliver more value, and win new business.

    Learn more
    • Locate a Partner
      Access our industry-leading partner network.
    • Value-Added Resellers
      Enter new markets, deliver more value, and get rewarded.
    • Managed Service Providers
      Meet customer needs with cybersecurity ratings.
    • ISAC Partner Program
      Learn more about the industries we support and ISAC member benefits.
    • Technology Alliances
      Access innovative solutions from leading providers.
    • SCORE Portal Login
      Use the SCORE Partner Program to grow your business.
    • SecurityScorecard Marketplace
      Find a trusted solution that extends your SecurityScorecard experience.

    Understand and reduce risk with SecurityScorecard.

    Free account sign up
  • Resources
    RESOURCES
    • Resource Center
      Explore our cybersecurity ebooks, data sheets, webinars, and more.
    • SecurityScorecard Blog
      Read the latest blog posts published weekly.
    • Research & Insights Center
      Access our research on the latest industry trends and sector developments.
    • SecurityScorecard Academy
      NEW
      Complete certification courses and earn industry-recognized badges.
    TOOLS AND DOCUMENTATION
    • Free Security Rating
      Get your free ratings report with customized security score.
    • Product Release Notes
      Visit our support portal for the latest release notes.
    • Free Account Signup
      Start monitoring your cybersecurity posture today.
    • Chrome Extension
      NEW
      Show the security rating of websites you visit.
    • Assessments ROI Calculator
      Calculate the ROI of automating questionnaires.
    Trust begins with transparency. Take a look at the data that drives our ratings.
    Learn more
  • Company

    Working at SecurityScorecard

    Committed to promoting diversity, inclusion, and collaboration–and having fun while doing it.

    Join our team
    • About Us
      SecurityScorecard is the global leader in cybersecurity ratings.
    • Leadership
      Meet the team that is making the world a safer place.
    • Press
      Explore our most recent press releases and coverage.
    • Events
      Join us at any of these upcoming industry events.
    • Policy Insights
      Raising the bar on cybersecurity with security ratings.
    • Careers
      APPLY TODAY
      Come join the SecurityScorecard team!
    • Contact Us
      Contact us with any questions, concerns, or thoughts.
    • Trust Portal
      Take an inside look at the data that drives our technology.
    • Help Center
      We are here to help with any questions or difficulties.
Request a demo
SecurityScorecard SecurityScorecard
  • Support
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Support
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Blog
SecurityScorecard SecurityScorecard
  • Products
    PRODUCTS
    • Security Ratings
      Identify security strengths across ten risk factors.
    • Security Data
      Get actionable, data-based insights.
    • Security Assessments
      Automate security questionnaire exchange.
    • Attack Surface Intelligence
      NEW
      On-demand contextualized global threat intelligence.
     
    • Automatic Vendor Detection
      Uncover your third and fourth party vendors.
    • Cyber Risk Quantification
      Translate cyber risk into financial impact.
    • Reporting Center
      Streamline cyber risk reporting.
    • SecurityScorecard Marketplace
      Discover and deploy pre-built integrations.
    BUY NOW
    • Compare All Plans
      Choose a plan that's right for your business.
    • Try Free Account
      Make informed decisions with confidence.
    • Buy Pro Now
      Add automated event responses.
    • Buy Business Now
      Expand on Pro with vendor management and integrations.
    • Request Enterprise Demo
      See the capabilities of an enterprise plan in action.
    icon__SSClogoMark icon__SSClogoMark

    Understand and reduce risk with SecurityScorecard.

    Free account sign up
  • Services
    SERVICES NEW
    • Digital Forensics & Incident Response
      Prepare to respond to any threat.
    • Third-Party Risk Management
      Reduce risk across your vendor ecosystem.
    • Cyber Risk Intelligence
      Partner to obtain meaningful threat intelligence.
     
    • Penetration Testing
      Uncover your vulnerabilities before an attack does.
    • Red Team
      Use scenarios to perform a simulated attack.
    • Tabletop Exercises
      Test your incident response plan & bolster your readiness.

    Under Cyber attack?

    Contact us for immediate support if you believe your organization is the victim of a cyber attack.

    Contact Cyber 911 Team
  • Solutions
    BY USE CASE
    • Compliance
    • Cyber Insurance
    • Digital Forensics
    • Due Diligence
    • Enterprise Cyber Risk
    • Executive-Level Reporting
    • Incident Response
    • Regulatory Oversight
    • Third-Party Risk
    BY INDUSTRY
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Financial Services
    • Government
    • Healthcare
    • Insurance
    • Retail & Consumer
    • Technology
    Help your organization calculate its risk
    View All Solutions
  • Customers
    OUR CUSTOMERS
    • Customer Overview
      Trusted by companies of all industries and sizes.
    • Peer Reviews
      Find out what our customers are saying.
    SUCCESS AND SUPPORT
    • Customer Success
      Receive award-winning customer service.
    • Support
      Get your questions answered by our experts.
    COMMUNITY
    • SecurityScorecard Connect
      Engage in fun, educational, and rewarding activities.
    • Connect Login
      Join our exclusive online customer community.
    icon__SSClogoMark icon__SSClogoMark
    Understand and reduce risk with SecurityScorecard.
    Free account sign up
  • Partners

    Partner Program Overview

    Partner with SecurityScorecard and leverage our global cybersecurity ratings leadership to expand your solution, deliver more value, and win new business.

    Learn more
    • Locate a Partner
      Access our industry-leading partner network.
    • Value-Added Resellers
      Enter new markets, deliver more value, and get rewarded.
    • Managed Service Providers
      Meet customer needs with cybersecurity ratings.
    • ISAC Partner Program
      Learn more about the industries we support and ISAC member benefits.
    • Technology Alliances
      Access innovative solutions from leading providers.
    • SCORE Portal Login
      Use the SCORE Partner Program to grow your business.
    • SecurityScorecard Marketplace
      Find a trusted solution that extends your SecurityScorecard experience.

    Understand and reduce risk with SecurityScorecard.

    Free account sign up
  • Resources
    RESOURCES
    • Resource Center
      Explore our cybersecurity ebooks, data sheets, webinars, and more.
    • SecurityScorecard Blog
      Read the latest blog posts published weekly.
    • Research & Insights Center
      Access our research on the latest industry trends and sector developments.
    • SecurityScorecard Academy
      NEW
      Complete certification courses and earn industry-recognized badges.
    TOOLS AND DOCUMENTATION
    • Free Security Rating
      Get your free ratings report with customized security score.
    • Product Release Notes
      Visit our support portal for the latest release notes.
    • Free Account Signup
      Start monitoring your cybersecurity posture today.
    • Chrome Extension
      NEW
      Show the security rating of websites you visit.
    • Assessments ROI Calculator
      Calculate the ROI of automating questionnaires.
    Trust begins with transparency. Take a look at the data that drives our ratings.
    Learn more
  • Company

    Working at SecurityScorecard

    Committed to promoting diversity, inclusion, and collaboration–and having fun while doing it.

    Join our team
    • About Us
      SecurityScorecard is the global leader in cybersecurity ratings.
    • Leadership
      Meet the team that is making the world a safer place.
    • Press
      Explore our most recent press releases and coverage.
    • Events
      Join us at any of these upcoming industry events.
    • Policy Insights
      Raising the bar on cybersecurity with security ratings.
    • Careers
      APPLY TODAY
      Come join the SecurityScorecard team!
    • Contact Us
      Contact us with any questions, concerns, or thoughts.
    • Trust Portal
      Take an inside look at the data that drives our technology.
    • Help Center
      We are here to help with any questions or difficulties.
Request a demo
SecurityScorecard SecurityScorecard
BLOG

What’s the Difference Between Red Teaming and Penetration Testing?

11/14/2022

When discussing cybersecurity, “penetration testing” and “red teaming” are two terms that are often used interchangeably but are two entirely separate concepts. If you are considering implementing additional cybersecurity protocols within your organization, it’s essential to understand the unique role and function of each of these processes and how they can benefit your organization.

In this post, we will discuss the definitions of each term, how they differ, and how to determine which test is best for you.

What is penetration testing?

Penetration testing, also known as “pen-testing,” is a systematic assessment process used to uncover vulnerabilities or threats within a specific network. Penetration testing is very methodical, with a clearly defined scope to focus on a specific, targeted aspect of an organization’s IT system.

Different types of penetration testing

Because penetration testing targets a single aspect of an IT system, there are several types of penetration tests that an organization can choose to run. These tests can be used to examine potential vulnerabilities or risks in new systems or software before deployment or assess systems that are already in place and operational.

Different types of penetration tests include:

Internal network test

This test type is designed to expose potential risks that would be present once a threat actor has gained access to an organization’s internal systems. In most cases, a tester performing an internal network test would be given some level of authorized access to begin the test. Internal network tests are useful for detecting insider threats from partners, contractors, or employees.

External network tests

Conversely, an external network test is designed to detect internet-facing vulnerabilities within a business by examining risks related to servers, firewalls, hosts, and other network-connected devices. External network tests do not require the tester to have authorized access to the system and are ideal for assessing threats posed by individuals from outside of the organization.

Wireless network tests

Wireless network tests evaluate the potential vulnerabilities of an organization’s Wi-Fi network. This may include attempting to evade WLAN protocols, discovering encryption weaknesses, or uncovering authorized users’ identities and credentials to access secured networks.

Web application tests

When performing web application tests, penetration testers focus on insecure elements in the design, publishing, and coding of a website or software application. These tests will seek to identify flaws in a database’s security, the configuration of web browsers, or the risk of cross-site scripting (XSS), among other things.

Phishing Exercises

Phishing exercises evaluate cybersecurity from an entirely different angle: the risk inherent from authorized users even if they do not have malicious intent. Phishing exercises use social engineering and “lures” the evaluate users’ cybersecurity hygiene and resistance to divulging sensitive information.

What is Red Teaming?

Red Teaming is an exercise which emulates real world tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) employed by threat actors to validate security controls with a focus on people, process, and technology. Red Teaming exercises are utilized by organizations with mature cybersecurity hygiene and advanced security controls.

What’s the difference between penetration testing and red teaming?

While red teaming and penetration testing are similar, they are not identical. To further clarify how penetration testing and red teaming vary, it is helpful to consider penetration testing as a subset of procedures that can be used as part of a comprehensive red team evaluation and is often used when a system-wide assessment is not required. Both types of tests are valuable and have their unique values and benefits.

Intent of test

There are several elements to consider when differentiating between penetration testing and red teaming. Two of the most useful aspects are “reach” and “access”:

  • “Reach” refers to the scope of the evaluation. This is one of the primary differences between penetration testing and red teaming. Where red teaming encompasses the entire system as a holistic unit, penetration testing focuses on a specific aspect, isolated at a distinct point in time.
  • “Access” refers to the approval required by the tester to conduct the evaluation. For penetration testing, access to the system may or may not be required and is specified in the scope of work prior to an assessment taking place. On the other hand, red teaming generally starts from ground zero with no access to best replicate the experience of a criminal hacker.

Penetration testing vs. red teaming: Which is right for you?

When deciding which assessment type is the best fit for your organization, here are a few things to consider:

Frequency of tests

Penetration testing is often much quicker to complete and can be conducted on a set schedule. In contrast, red teaming varies in time to complete and may be completed over a much longer timeframe.

Time and cost efficiency

Has your organization conducted any other threat assessments? Do you need a comprehensive evaluation or just a test for a new system or software? Red teaming is a better fit when assessing top-to-bottom security systems but would not be time- or cost-effective to vet a single application or element.

Experience

Whether you are considering conducting evaluations internally or hiring an external expert, penetration testing and red teaming requires different skill sets, and knowing what outcome is desired should help guide the choice of who conducts the assessment. Red teaming requires deep technical expertise, awareness, and ability to emulate real world threat actor TTPs not only focused on technical security controls but people and processes. Penetration testing requires profound and specific knowledge of one particular area of concern to thoroughly vet that system or aspect for any potential weaknesses.

Cybersecurity testing with SecurityScorecard

Both test types can provide value to an organization. Ideally, both should be used as part of a comprehensive cybersecurity strategy. For organizations looking to implement their own testing protocols, SecurityScorecard offers active security services, including penetration testing, incident response exercises, tabletop exercises, and red teaming to help simplify and systematize the myriad of cybersecurity testing options available today. Our experts can validate existing security measures and uncover potential threats that place your business at risk to ensure compliance, security, and peace of mind.

Interested in learning more? Contact us today to receive more information on our redacted reports and methodologies to save your business from potential vulnerabilities and future cyber threats.

Return to Blog
Join us in making the world a safer place.
FREE ACCOUNT SIGN UP
Products
Solutions
Customers
Marketplace
Partners
Resources
Company
Trust Portal
Security Ratings
Login
Blog
Contact
Careers

SecurityScorecard
Tower 49
12 E 49th St
Suite 15-100
New York, NY 10017

[email protected]

United States: (800) 682-1701
International: +1(646) 809-2166
Social-linkedin Social-facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube